In the blow-by-blow account of the Democratic race for President, many pundits are ignoring the importance of superdelegates in the nominating process. Superdelegates are unelected and unaffected by primaries and caucuses and will comprise a voting bloc of almost one-third of the total at the Democratic Convention. They are primarily members of the Party establishment including Congresspeople, officials and other entrenched interests. These superdelegates favor Hillary overwhelmingly over the upstart campaign of Barack Obama.
How did this "undemocratic" situation develop? Well, initially, in rebellion to the process of picking a Presidential candidate in a "smoke-filled" back room, the Democratic Party moved almost exclusively to state primaries. The only problem: the Democratic base sometimes got a little carried away. For example, in 1972, they chose the liberal icon, George McGovern, who went down to a resounding defeat in the general election. After that debacle, the Party decided to place a check on public opinion by creating superdelegates.
Though some decry this situation, it's actually a good thing. Our Founding Fathers were always concerned about the "tyranny of the majority," the possibility of a demagogue coming to power. That's one reason why they formed the Senate and gave Senators six-year terms to avoid any mass-induced hysteria from Representatives in the House. Let's remember that sometimes direct elections, in and of themselves, fail to produce the best result. For example, the victory of Hamas in Palestinian elections.
And sometimes you do need wiser, more experienced voices to exert some influence. So, while Barack Obama is dazzling us with his oratory, the Party elders, the superdelegates, may choose a more experienced candidate. This is beneficial for the Democratic Party and the country.
Saturday, January 26, 2008
Saturday, January 19, 2008
Nevada and Rolling the Dice
It's somehow fitting to see the role Nevada is playing in the Democratic primaries. Former President Bill Clinton said we would be rolling the dice if we elected Barack Obama. Despite the controversy generated by the statement, the argument is valid for a number of reasons.
1) Power changes people. Different people react to power, especially immense power, in different ways. For example, Dick Cheney, though admittedly an arch conservative, was viewed with a degree of respect before he became Vice President. Since then, his efforts to aggrandize himself and the executive branch, combined with his blatant warmongering, and his disregard for fundamental elements of the Constitution, have transformed him into a different person. His character now is repugnant to most Americans.
Barack Obama's youth makes him especially vulnerable to the effects of immense power.
2) Politics is a game of images, and the things people say to get elected may be vastly different from their inner agenda. Presidential candidate George W. Bush said he wanted to be a uniter not a divider. We all know how quickly that promise was discarded.
3) The best barometer in evaluating political candidates, given the two points above, is their prior record. There seems to be an element of calculation, compared to inner beliefs, in Barack Obama's record. For example, he voted "present" instead of yea or nay on many votes while he was a state legislator. You can't vote "present" when you're President. You have to take a stand. That stand is harder to discern than for someone with a record like Hillary Clinton.
So, yes, there is an element of rolling the dice with Barack Obama. I'm not saying he couldn't be a good or even great President, only that it's difficult to render a verdict at this stage.
1) Power changes people. Different people react to power, especially immense power, in different ways. For example, Dick Cheney, though admittedly an arch conservative, was viewed with a degree of respect before he became Vice President. Since then, his efforts to aggrandize himself and the executive branch, combined with his blatant warmongering, and his disregard for fundamental elements of the Constitution, have transformed him into a different person. His character now is repugnant to most Americans.
Barack Obama's youth makes him especially vulnerable to the effects of immense power.
2) Politics is a game of images, and the things people say to get elected may be vastly different from their inner agenda. Presidential candidate George W. Bush said he wanted to be a uniter not a divider. We all know how quickly that promise was discarded.
3) The best barometer in evaluating political candidates, given the two points above, is their prior record. There seems to be an element of calculation, compared to inner beliefs, in Barack Obama's record. For example, he voted "present" instead of yea or nay on many votes while he was a state legislator. You can't vote "present" when you're President. You have to take a stand. That stand is harder to discern than for someone with a record like Hillary Clinton.
So, yes, there is an element of rolling the dice with Barack Obama. I'm not saying he couldn't be a good or even great President, only that it's difficult to render a verdict at this stage.
Saturday, January 12, 2008
Barack Obama: Let the Buyer Beware
There is indeed something going in the Barack Obama campaign, but it requires a closer look. The first time I heard him speak since his keynote address at the Democratic Convention, Mr. Obama was giving his victory address after the Iowa caucus. Despite being a committed supporter of Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton, I must admit I was taken in by his soaring oratory and plea for unity.
As the campaign progressed, and I heard more of his speeches, I came to realize he wasn't saying very much. Yes, the words and sentiments were eloquent, but it was like the old Wendy's commercial, "Where's the beef?" Slowly, it dawned on me that everyone brought their own hopes and aspirations to these rallies, and transposed them onto what Obama was saying. Thus, the speeches served as a template for our individual needs.
With all due respect to Mr. Obama and the historic campaign he is waging, this is a dangerous thing. Even if the messenger is well meaning, the fact that masses of people are flocking to his campaign suggests we, as a people, may be vulnerable to a demagogue. Not that Barack is one, just that Americans are often a little naive. Mr. Obama is exploiting that fact like any good politician who tries to avoid unnecessarily alienating groups of voters by being too specific.
Now, I don't really know Mr. Obama very well, and I prefer Hillary because I know where she stands and her true concern for all Americans. But it is difficult for her to compete against someone who stirs the longing and desparation we all feel at times.
So, here's just a note of caution: Caveat Emptor... Let the buyer beware.
As the campaign progressed, and I heard more of his speeches, I came to realize he wasn't saying very much. Yes, the words and sentiments were eloquent, but it was like the old Wendy's commercial, "Where's the beef?" Slowly, it dawned on me that everyone brought their own hopes and aspirations to these rallies, and transposed them onto what Obama was saying. Thus, the speeches served as a template for our individual needs.
With all due respect to Mr. Obama and the historic campaign he is waging, this is a dangerous thing. Even if the messenger is well meaning, the fact that masses of people are flocking to his campaign suggests we, as a people, may be vulnerable to a demagogue. Not that Barack is one, just that Americans are often a little naive. Mr. Obama is exploiting that fact like any good politician who tries to avoid unnecessarily alienating groups of voters by being too specific.
Now, I don't really know Mr. Obama very well, and I prefer Hillary because I know where she stands and her true concern for all Americans. But it is difficult for her to compete against someone who stirs the longing and desparation we all feel at times.
So, here's just a note of caution: Caveat Emptor... Let the buyer beware.
Monday, December 31, 2007
My Year in Review
It seems fitting to conclude this year's My Week in Review blog with an entry titled "My Year in Review."
The blog focuses on three major topic areas: Politics, Religion and Public Relations, and I'll focus on each one in turn.
First, PR. This year has been a productive one for our company, Cut-It-Out Communications, and we've achieved several major goals. These include reaching the level of four major clients on full retainer, changing the company name (from Cut-It-Out Editing) and hiring consultants for a major overhaul of our website, to be completed in January. We've also expanded our offerings significantly, starting a new interactive program for our clients including blogs, online press releases, e-newsletters and online content syndication. We now also provide new structured web pages for client sites, primarily for press releases and forwarding of newsletter articles, so visitors can access the website directly instead of linking to a pdf file.
Religion: Well, our annual Bob Dylan Christmas card stirred the usual praise and controversy. We've also been published on lohud.com (the online site for The Journal News) with a critique of the Religious Right and the issue of immigration. This blog was launched in the second half of the year, allowing an outlet for opinions about the link between politics and true Christianity.
Politics: Cut-It-Out Communications added new clients in the County Legislature and Greenburgh town hall. Support for Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton's campaign for President took various forms, including a full-page creative word-scramble advertisement in the journal for the Annual Dinner of the Westchester County Democratic Committee.
We're looking forward to fruition in many of these fields in an exciting 2008.
The blog focuses on three major topic areas: Politics, Religion and Public Relations, and I'll focus on each one in turn.
First, PR. This year has been a productive one for our company, Cut-It-Out Communications, and we've achieved several major goals. These include reaching the level of four major clients on full retainer, changing the company name (from Cut-It-Out Editing) and hiring consultants for a major overhaul of our website, to be completed in January. We've also expanded our offerings significantly, starting a new interactive program for our clients including blogs, online press releases, e-newsletters and online content syndication. We now also provide new structured web pages for client sites, primarily for press releases and forwarding of newsletter articles, so visitors can access the website directly instead of linking to a pdf file.
Religion: Well, our annual Bob Dylan Christmas card stirred the usual praise and controversy. We've also been published on lohud.com (the online site for The Journal News) with a critique of the Religious Right and the issue of immigration. This blog was launched in the second half of the year, allowing an outlet for opinions about the link between politics and true Christianity.
Politics: Cut-It-Out Communications added new clients in the County Legislature and Greenburgh town hall. Support for Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton's campaign for President took various forms, including a full-page creative word-scramble advertisement in the journal for the Annual Dinner of the Westchester County Democratic Committee.
We're looking forward to fruition in many of these fields in an exciting 2008.
Wednesday, December 26, 2007
A Bob Dylan Christmas
Apologies for the late post this week. Even bloggers take vacations.
For those of you who didn't receive one, my Christmas card, sent to friends, church members and my company's associates at Cut-It-Out Communications, provides the mixture of politics, religion and common sense central to this blog.
Here is the text:
When You Gonna Wake Up
by Bob Dylan
God don’t make promises that He don’t keep.
You got some big dreams, baby, but in order to dream,
You gotta still be asleep.
Chorus: When you gonna wake up,
When you gonna wake up, When you gonna wake up,
Strengthen the things that remain.
Counterfeit philosophies have polluted all of your thoughts.
Karl Marx has got you by the throat,
And Henry Kissinger’s got you tied up into knots. [Chorus]
You got innocent men in jail, your insane asylums are filled.
You got unrighteous doctors,
Dealing drugs that’ll never cure your ills. [Chorus]
You got men who can’t hold their peace,
Women who can’t control their tongue.
The rich seduce the poor, and the old are seduced by the young. [Chorus]
Adulterers in churches, and pornography in the schools.
You got gangsters in power,
And lawbreakers making rules. [Chorus]
Spiritual advisors and gurus to guide your every move.
Instant inner peace,
And every step you take’s got to be approved. [Chorus]
Do you ever wonder just what God requires?
You think He’s just an errand boy,
To satisfy your wandering desires? [Chorus]
You can’t take it with you, and you know it’s too worthless to be sold.
They tell you, “Time is money,”
As if your life was worth its weight in gold.
There’s a man on a cross, and He be crucified for you.
Believe in His power,
That’s about all you gotta do. [Chorus]
Merry Christmas and Happy New Year.
For those of you who didn't receive one, my Christmas card, sent to friends, church members and my company's associates at Cut-It-Out Communications, provides the mixture of politics, religion and common sense central to this blog.
Here is the text:
When You Gonna Wake Up
by Bob Dylan
God don’t make promises that He don’t keep.
You got some big dreams, baby, but in order to dream,
You gotta still be asleep.
Chorus: When you gonna wake up,
When you gonna wake up, When you gonna wake up,
Strengthen the things that remain.
Counterfeit philosophies have polluted all of your thoughts.
Karl Marx has got you by the throat,
And Henry Kissinger’s got you tied up into knots. [Chorus]
You got innocent men in jail, your insane asylums are filled.
You got unrighteous doctors,
Dealing drugs that’ll never cure your ills. [Chorus]
You got men who can’t hold their peace,
Women who can’t control their tongue.
The rich seduce the poor, and the old are seduced by the young. [Chorus]
Adulterers in churches, and pornography in the schools.
You got gangsters in power,
And lawbreakers making rules. [Chorus]
Spiritual advisors and gurus to guide your every move.
Instant inner peace,
And every step you take’s got to be approved. [Chorus]
Do you ever wonder just what God requires?
You think He’s just an errand boy,
To satisfy your wandering desires? [Chorus]
You can’t take it with you, and you know it’s too worthless to be sold.
They tell you, “Time is money,”
As if your life was worth its weight in gold.
There’s a man on a cross, and He be crucified for you.
Believe in His power,
That’s about all you gotta do. [Chorus]
Merry Christmas and Happy New Year.
Saturday, December 15, 2007
Top 10 Reasons to Vote for Hillary
With all due respect to David Letterman, please see below the top 10 reasons to vote for Hillary. Unlike Mr. Letterman, however, these reasons are serious because they address a very serious topic, the future of our country.
10. Hillary knows what it's like to live in the fishbowl of the White House and has learned how to be circumspect in her words and actions. Some people misinterpret this talent as running a tightly scripted campaign.
9. Hillary gets rave reviews for her performance as a U.S. Senator. Despite initial misgivings by many New Yorkers, she humbled herself in the Senate, worked hard and listened to Senators with more seniority. The result: she was re-elected to the Senate in a landslide and universally acclaimed by New York Democrats and Republicans alike.
8. Her closest advisor is Bill Clinton, who, despite personal weaknesses, created the most properous economic climate in decades when he was President.
7. Hillary has perseverance and grit, essential components of the job description for President. She handled the Lewinsky affair with uncommon poise and determination.
6. Hillary understands the health care system in the United States better than any other candidate, and this is one of the most important issues facing our society today.
5. It would be good for our country for a woman to be elected President.
4. Hillary has deplored the excesses of the Bush administration, from suspension of habeus corpus to waterboarding, and has pledged to reverse them.
3. Hillary understands the importance of dialogue and listening, in general, and especially during crisis situations.
2. You can trust Hillary to work for her beliefs because she has done so her entire life.
AND #1
Hillary is most likely to win in November, and our country can't afford four more years of a Republican administration.
10. Hillary knows what it's like to live in the fishbowl of the White House and has learned how to be circumspect in her words and actions. Some people misinterpret this talent as running a tightly scripted campaign.
9. Hillary gets rave reviews for her performance as a U.S. Senator. Despite initial misgivings by many New Yorkers, she humbled herself in the Senate, worked hard and listened to Senators with more seniority. The result: she was re-elected to the Senate in a landslide and universally acclaimed by New York Democrats and Republicans alike.
8. Her closest advisor is Bill Clinton, who, despite personal weaknesses, created the most properous economic climate in decades when he was President.
7. Hillary has perseverance and grit, essential components of the job description for President. She handled the Lewinsky affair with uncommon poise and determination.
6. Hillary understands the health care system in the United States better than any other candidate, and this is one of the most important issues facing our society today.
5. It would be good for our country for a woman to be elected President.
4. Hillary has deplored the excesses of the Bush administration, from suspension of habeus corpus to waterboarding, and has pledged to reverse them.
3. Hillary understands the importance of dialogue and listening, in general, and especially during crisis situations.
2. You can trust Hillary to work for her beliefs because she has done so her entire life.
AND #1
Hillary is most likely to win in November, and our country can't afford four more years of a Republican administration.
Saturday, December 8, 2007
Things Get Interesting
Political junkies really got their fix this week. Of course, anyone with even a passing interest in politics knows a week can be like six months in any other profession. That's why it's so preposterous to predict who the next President will be.
Anyway, Mike Huckabee is the toast of the town, and, even though I'm a staunch Democrat, I must admit he's cast an impressive penumbra over both Parties this week. My interest, as a Pentecostal Christian myself, concerns his willingness to think independently and not pander to the Religious Right. He says, powerfully, that life does not end at birth, something the anti-abortion movement seems to forget. A true Christian should address poverty, adequate healthcare, affordable housing, etc., in addition to protecting the fetus.
Also, Mr. Huckabee refuses to pander to the hating, nativist, anti-immigrant crowd. He defends the immigrant as a human being, something the rest of his Party seems to forget.
Mike Huckabee's meteoric rise obscured a major development in the other Party, namely Barack Obama's rise to number one in the opinion polls. I don't think personally that he would make a good President, mainly because of his inexperience. With Hillary, I know what I'm getting, and she's been an activist since her days at Wellesley.
So, let's see how the frontrunner dynamic plays out next week. There may be a slight falling back as the new stars receive increased scrutiny from the press and their opponents.
Anyway, Mike Huckabee is the toast of the town, and, even though I'm a staunch Democrat, I must admit he's cast an impressive penumbra over both Parties this week. My interest, as a Pentecostal Christian myself, concerns his willingness to think independently and not pander to the Religious Right. He says, powerfully, that life does not end at birth, something the anti-abortion movement seems to forget. A true Christian should address poverty, adequate healthcare, affordable housing, etc., in addition to protecting the fetus.
Also, Mr. Huckabee refuses to pander to the hating, nativist, anti-immigrant crowd. He defends the immigrant as a human being, something the rest of his Party seems to forget.
Mike Huckabee's meteoric rise obscured a major development in the other Party, namely Barack Obama's rise to number one in the opinion polls. I don't think personally that he would make a good President, mainly because of his inexperience. With Hillary, I know what I'm getting, and she's been an activist since her days at Wellesley.
So, let's see how the frontrunner dynamic plays out next week. There may be a slight falling back as the new stars receive increased scrutiny from the press and their opponents.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




